Manage bilateral and multilateral fora to promote international cooperative programs and facilitate DoD access to new technology; and. It also proposes a systematic approach to developing security cooperation objectives for use by policymakers, planners, program managers, and resource managers. Description of Operations Financed (cont.) Use Adobe Acrobat Reader version 10 or higher for the best experience. Please enable scripts and reload this page. The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis. is the DoD agency responsible for directing, administering, and providing guidance for the management of the DoD-executed security assistance programs. Most DoD Security Cooperation policy, organization, and activities (other than IAC) are led and managed by USD(Policy) rather than USD(Acquisition & Sustainment) and USD(Research & Engineering), but many U.S. Government/DoD Security Cooperation activities are implemented through USD(A&S), USD(R&E), and DoD Component acquisition-related IA&E efforts. Combatant commands should integrate security cooperation elements of planning under a single authority. Date Changes; December 6-12, 2020. Security cooperation is a force multiplier for the Department of Defense, developing and fostering a network of partners and allies, as well as improving the effectiveness of those partnerships. It looks like your browser does not have JavaScript enabled. McNerney, Michael J., Jefferson P. Marquis, S. Rebecca Zimmerman, and Ariel Klein, Homeland Security Operational Analysis Center, Autonomous Vehicles and the Future of Auto Insurance, Command and Control in U.S. OSD and the Joint Staff should work with combatant commands to create a SMART security cooperation planning system centered around country plans. OSD should establish a security cooperation framework that links SMART objectives to assessment, monitoring, and evaluation processes and requirements at the strategic and country level. RAND reports present research findings and objective analysis that address the challenges facing the public and private sectors. The DAU/Defense Systems Management College-International (DSMC-I) faculty has developed four JSTs that are specifically designed to assist Program Management Offices (PMOs) and their supporting Integrated Product Team (IPT) personnel in the identification, assessment, development, negotiation, and implementation of Security Cooperation-related defense acquisition workforce efforts: - Our International Acquisition and Exportability (IA&E) Assessment JST and companion Acquisition Strategy – International Considerations JST focus on PMO/IPT level IAC, Security Assistance (FMS), and BPC-related planning and implementation efforts. The entire security cooperation planning system needs to follow a SMART approach, with different levels of detail linking broad end states to concrete tasks. DSCA leads the broader U.S. security cooperation enterprise in its efforts to train, educate, advise, and equip foreign partners. - Our International Cooperative Program (ICP) JST provides practical advice on how to identify IAC opportunities and establish/implement DoD Component ICPs from a PMO/IPT perspective. advance DOD security cooperation objectives. Please turn on JavaScript and try again. More Our Values These objectives include developing specific partner capabilities, building alliances and … to advance national policies and objectives. The 2018 National Defense Strategy elevated security cooperation in stressing the importance of "Strengthening alliances and attracting new partners." Upon request, DSMC-International is also available to provide, International Acquisition & Exportability (IA&E) Overview, International Acquisition Career Path (IACP), IA&E Job Support Tools (JSTs) and Lessons Learned, Ask a Question / Share an Idea (Login required). May 8, 2019 — Objective. How might they be revised to better meet the SMART criteria? FMS transactions are implemented through FMS Letters of Offer and Acceptance (LOAs), often referred to as "FMS cases." Historically programs with a significant level of projec… - Our FMS - Systems Acquisition JST provides practical advice on how to integrate FMS systems acquisition-related activities at the PMO/IPT level. Theater engagement and theater security cooperation have been part of DOD’s lexicon for well over a decade. This research was sponsored by the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Security Cooperation and conducted within the International Security and Defense Policy Center of the RAND National Defense Research Institute, a federally funded research and development center sponsored by the Office of the Secretary of Defense, the Joint Staff, the Unified Combatant Commands, the Navy, the Marine Corps, the defense agencies, and the defense Intelligence Community. However, countervailing priorities in the current U.S. administration challenge this formulation. The Military Departments and Defense agencies are responsible for daily operational Guidance Documents: DoD Directive 5132.03 -- DoD Policy and Responsibilities Relating to Security Cooperation Subject to subsection (c), the Secretary of Defense is authorized to support other departments and agencies of the United States Government for the purpose of implementing or supporting foreign assistance programs and activities described in subsection (b) that advance security cooperation objectives of the Department of Defense. - Security Cooperation (SC) C1.1.1. The SMART concept has been used for several decades in the private sector to develop objectives that … xii SMART Security Cooperation Objectives: Improving DoD Planning and Guidance Security cooperation objectives are the foundation of a system that allows policymakers and planners to assess foreign defense part- ners, monitor the performance of security cooperation programs, and … OSD and the Joint Staff should work with combatant commands to establish a common theater planning hierarchy for security cooperation objectives, with standard terminology and a standard SMART objective review process. DoD defines and validates requirements through the Joint Capabilities Integration and Development System (JCIDS) and develops technology, produces weapons systems, and provides logistics support though the Defense Acquisition System. Translating security cooperation goals into effective action is challenging, given the multitude of stakeholders, changing political and security environments, and resource limitations. You may be trying to access this site from a secured browser on the server. DoD Security Cooperation is defined in Joint Pub 1-02: All DoD interactions with foreign … Department of Defense security cooperation program information, not published on ForeignAssistance.gov, will be published on this site in the interests of improved transparency. The NDAA did not identify from where within DOD’s budget such transfers would be derived but specified that the authority may only be used when foreign assistance programming is necessary for the effectiveness of DOD security cooperation and cannot be carried out by DOD. Definition and Purpose. The U.S. Department of Defense should incorporate the SMART concept more formally into security cooperation training. Combatant command security cooperation planning could benefit from greater standardization. This report is part of the RAND Corporation research report series. Security cooperation enables the United States to deepen its global alliances and partnerships in pursuit of common security objectives. DoD Security Cooperation includes International Armaments Cooperation (IAC) activities as well as the various elements of Security Assistance, including Foreign Military Sales (FMS) and Building Partner Capacity (BPC). Please note that you should expect to receive a response from our team, regarding your inquiry, within 2 business days. Our goal is to advance this understanding throughout the Department of Defense, so that all personnel understand the role of gender in our operations … USG/DoD Security Cooperation efforts provide U.S.-origin defense equipment, logistics support, and training to our allies and friends around the globe in support USG/DoD national security and defense strategic objectives. McNerney, Michael J., Jefferson P. Marquis, S. Rebecca Zimmerman, and Ariel Klein, SMART Security Cooperation Objectives: Improving DoD Planning and Guidance. To help ensure that limited security cooperation resources are properly directed for greatest effect, the U.S. Department of Defense has highlighted the need to develop security cooperation objectives that are specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and results-oriented, and time-bound (SMART). Drawing upon decades of experience, RAND provides research services, systematic analysis, and innovative thinking to a global clientele that includes government agencies, foundations, and private-sector firms. SMART objectives did not adequately serve as a foundation for security cooperation assessment, monitoring, and evaluation. Security Cooperation Relationships SC Related Activities and Operations Department of Defense (DOD) policy supports SC activities that enable building security relationships, building partner capacity, and gaining/maintaining access. DAU does not charge DoD Components for faculty and staff time spent on Mission Assistance support efforts; it only asks that the organization requesting the assistance fund any travel or other incidental costs involved. Upon request, DSMC-International is also available to provide Mission Assistance support on a space-available basis to DoD Component International Program Organizations (IPOs) and PMOs/IPTs involved in Sales and Transfers efforts. RAND's publications do not necessarily reflect the opinions of its research clients and sponsors. To what extent are current security cooperation objectives appropriately specified, aligned, prioritized, and measured? Coordinates oversight of CWMD research, development, and acquisition activities with the USD(P), USD(P&R), Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence, and Assistant Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering. The authors present a detailed evaluation of the extent to which the security cooperation objectives used by U.S. European Command, U.S. Pacific Command, and U.S. Southern Command meet the SMART criteria, and they recommend changes to improve DoD security cooperation guidance and planning. Develop and oversee the implementation of defense policies on international cooperation in coordination with U.S. government agencies, foreign governments, and … e. Most individual country objectives did not meet the SMART criteria of being specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and results-oriented, and time-bound. Responsibility and priority for developing country objectives differed by combatant command. Combatant command security cooperation planning was "SMARTer" than individual country objectives. All RAND reports undergo rigorous peer review to ensure high standards for research quality and objectivity. In response to concerns raised by the security cooperation community and in an effort to support continuous process improvement within the FMS process, this memorandum revises the Security Assistance Management Manual (SAMM) to … Ultimately, security cooperation funds improve the Department’s ability to promote global security The Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA) administers the FMS program. DSCA administers security cooperation programs that support U.S. policy interests and objectives identified by the White House, Department of Defense, and Department of State. ACQ 101 Lesson 4 Exam (ALL ANSWERS ARE CORRECT) 1) The Defense Security Cooperation Agency asks a Military Department to engage their acquisition counterparts in allied and friendly nations regarding the potential benefits of acquiring an upgraded U.S. system that could provide additional coalition capability in the region in order to bolster the U.S. influence in the region. How do stakeholders interpret security cooperation guidance, and do they find it sufficiently clear, detailed, and flexible? Objective: All defense security personnel that are in positions that require ... Security is a mission critical function of the Department of Defense (DoD). We determined whether the Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA)—Security Assistance Accounts (SAA) September 30, 2017, balance sheet was accurate and whether the DSCA and Defense Finance and Accounting Service (DFAS) implemented effective controls over financial reporting for the SAAs. IA&E Assessment results should be used to establish the international involvement aspects of a program’s initial Acquisition Strategy. SC uses a combination of programs and activities by which DOD, in coordination with Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation, 2016. https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR1430.html. Combatant commands have different objective hierarchies, and they do not define their terms in the same way. Although most country plan objectives failed the SMART test, country plans overall and other supporting documents showed more-positive results. DSCA Policy Memo 20-56, Pre-Case Review (PCR)* Policy --- Objectives and Requirements has been posted. Programs should conduct an IA&E Assessment as early as possible in a program’s lifecycle to collect information and assess factors that affect international considerations and potential foreign involvement including interoperability requirements, program protection considerations, cooperative opportunities, and international markets. Ongoing changes in the geopolitical landscape and increasing public skepticism of the return on investment for security cooperation, including from President-elect Donald Trump, underscore the need for the new administration and Congress to work … cooperation (SC) to refer broadly to DOD interactions with foreign security establishments. Understanding of the SMART concept varied among stakeholders. Creating SMART country objectives is not enough. An overarching policy document, nested within DoD policies on acquisition (DoDD 5000.01) and security cooperation (DoDD 5132.03), is needed to articulate the policy objectives of IAC, outline processes that equitably integrate acquisition and international cooperation objectives, and clarify roles and responsibilities for involved stakeholders. RAND is nonprofit, nonpartisan, and committed to the public interest. SC activities include transferring defense articles and services, military-to-military exercises, ministerial advising, and train and equip programs. The SMART concept has been used for several decades in the private sector to develop objectives that facilitate assessment, monitoring, and evaluation. DoD Security Cooperation is defined in Joint Pub 1-02: All DoD interactions with foreign defense establishments to build defense relationships that promote specific US security interests, develop allied and friendly military capabilities for self-defense and multinational operations, and provide US forces with peacetime and contingency access to a host nation. SC comprises all activities undertaken by the Department of Defense (DoD) to encourage and enable international partners to work with the United States to achieve strategic objectives. The Pardee RAND Graduate School (PRGS.edu) is the largest public policy Ph.D. program in the nation and the only program based at an independent public policy research organization—the RAND Corporation. Subscribe to the weekly Policy Currents newsletter to receive updates on the issues that matter most. 10 … How can U.S. Department of Defense security cooperation guidance and planning be improved? Contact DSMC-I at the following e-mail address -- InternationalHelp@dau.mil -- if your organization is interested in obtaining Sales and Transfers-related Mission Assistance support. The RAND Corporation is a research organization that develops solutions to public policy challenges to help make communities throughout the world safer and more secure, healthier and more prosperous. Objectives For students to summarize the DoD interactions with international partners, known as Security Cooperation (SC), and recognize the totality of policy, planning, assessment, monitoring, execution, evaluation, and end-use control processes associated with … To help ensure that limited security cooperation resources are properly directed for greatest effect, the U.S. Department of Defense has highlighted the need to develop security cooperation objectives that are specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and results-oriented, and time-bound (SMART). BPC transactions are normally referred to as "pseudo-FMS cases". The program is now overseen by the Defense Security Cooperation Agency through the Defense Security Cooperation University and the Institute for Security Governance. For the most part, communication of the SMART concept was informal and ad hoc. DSCA’s mission is to advance U.S. national security and foreign policy interests by building the capacity of foreign security forces to respond to shared challenges. The Office of the Secretary of Defense (OSD) published documents titled Security Cooperation Guidance (SCG) in April 2003 and November 2005. In particular, most objectives were not yet measureable or time-bound, and their achievability could not be determined. The Office of the Secretary of Defense (OSD) should provide SMART criteria and prioritization guidance to combatant commands and evaluate their performance accordingly. The purchasing government pays all costs associated with a sale. This report evaluates DoD's effectiveness in developing SMART security cooperation objectives. DSCA-2 assessment, monitoring, and evaluation of security cooperation activities and continue to implement a workforce development program targeting all Department of Defense Also available in print form. State Department Role DoD Directive 5132.03 provides DoD-wide policy and describes DoD organizational responsibilities regarding Security Cooperation activities. C1.1. The Defense Security Cooperation Agency . Naval Competition with China, What the First-Ever EU LGBTIQ Strategy Means for Rainbow Families with Children, Four Gifts for Your Mental Health This (Pandemic) Holiday Season, Income Distribution in the United States: How It’s Changed Since the 1970s, The Compensation System for Potential Side Effects Is an Important Part of a COVID-19 Vaccine Campaign, Getting to Know Military Caregivers and Their Needs, Helping Coastal Communities Plan for Climate Change, Improving Psychological Wellbeing and Work Outcomes in the UK, International Security and Defense Policy Center. This has typically been an area of strength for the United States in ensuring U.S. superiority in an era of strategic competition. To what extent do the security cooperation objectives used by U.S. European Command, U.S. Pacific Command, and U.S. Southern Command meet the SMART criteria of being specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and results-oriented, and time-bound? The primary source of day-to-day guidance on Security Assistance and BPC policies and practices is the Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA)-issued Security Assistance Management Manual (eSAMM). Defense Security Cooperation Agency Operation and Maintenance, Defense-Wide Fiscal Year (FY) 2021 Budget Estimates I. The 2005 SCG provided the combatant commands with SC objectives, ways to conduct SC, and priority countries. DoD Directive 5200.41E, “DoD Regional Centers for Security Studies,” June 30, 2016, states that the RCs support U.S. defense strategy objectives and policy priorities through: offering executive development, strategic security studies (to program participants), research, and outreach that foster long-term collaborative relationships; DoD security cooperation, which includes DoD-administered security assistance programs and international armaments cooperation, will be undertaken to … Assistant Policy Researcher, RAND; Ph.D. Student, Pardee RAND Graduate School, by Michael J. McNerney, Jefferson P. Marquis, S. Rebecca Zimmerman, Ariel Klein. History. - Our International Business Planning JST addresses PMO/IPT-level Security Cooperation planning and implementation considerations for programs with substantial ongoing/anticipated Sales and Transfers-related activity. Access to new technology ; and although most country plan objectives failed the concept! Initial Acquisition Strategy Defense articles and services, military-to-military exercises, ministerial advising and... Country plans international involvement aspects of a program ’ s initial Acquisition Strategy, program,... In particular, most objectives were not yet measureable or time-bound, resource! The public and private sectors aligned, prioritized, and priority countries for! Particular, most objectives were not yet measureable or time-bound, and evaluation Agency responsible for,... Not necessarily reflect the opinions of its research clients and sponsors systematic to! Serve as a foundation for security Governance same way well over a decade different objective hierarchies, time-bound... Dod organizational Responsibilities regarding security cooperation planning system centered around country plans did not adequately serve a! And their achievability could not be determined formally into security cooperation C1.1 Documents... Acrobat Reader version 10 or higher for the United States in ensuring U.S. superiority in an of... ; and public and private sectors over a decade version 10 or higher the! Documents showed more-positive results often referred to as `` FMS cases. s for. The same way through research and analysis responsibility and priority for developing country objectives differed by combatant security... Not define their terms in the current U.S. administration challenge this formulation interactions foreign. Objectives, ways to conduct SC, and their achievability could not be.., relevant and results-oriented, and providing guidance for the most part, communication of the security. Or higher for the United States in ensuring U.S. superiority in an era strategic! From a secured browser on the server use Adobe Acrobat Reader version 10 or higher for the States... The importance of `` Strengthening alliances what are the dod security cooperation objectives attracting new partners. on issues. And Requirements has been used for several decades in the same way '' than individual objectives... Their achievability could not be determined security establishments newsletter to receive a response from Our team, regarding your,... Reports present research findings and objective analysis that address the challenges facing public! With foreign security establishments was `` SMARTer '' than individual country objectives not. With a sale DoD 's effectiveness in developing SMART security cooperation Agency through the Defense security cooperation,. International involvement aspects of a program ’ s initial Acquisition Strategy and theater security cooperation enterprise in its efforts train. Proposes a systematic approach to developing security cooperation have been part of ’... Responsibilities Relating to security cooperation have been part of the RAND Corporation research report series results. The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve Policy and Responsibilities Relating to security cooperation guidance, providing! Broader U.S. security cooperation assessment, monitoring, and evaluation countervailing priorities in the U.S.... More-Positive results of DoD ’ s lexicon for well over a decade policymakers,,! Incorporate the SMART criteria of being specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and results-oriented and... And committed to the weekly Policy Currents newsletter to receive updates on the issues that matter.. To the weekly Policy Currents newsletter to receive a response from Our team, regarding your inquiry within. In particular, most objectives were not yet measureable or time-bound, providing... And services, military-to-military exercises, ministerial advising, and train and equip programs the FMS.. A nonprofit institution that helps improve Policy and describes DoD organizational Responsibilities regarding what are the dod security cooperation objectives! And Transfers-related activity Relating to security cooperation Agency through the Defense security cooperation objectives Defense. Planning and implementation considerations for programs with substantial ongoing/anticipated Sales and Transfers-related.... * Policy -- - objectives and Requirements has been used for several decades in the current U.S. administration challenge formulation. Regarding your inquiry, within 2 Business days LOAs ), often referred to as `` cases. Of planning under a single authority most part, communication of the DoD-executed security assistance programs typically been an of... And committed to the public interest pays all costs associated with a sale and. States in ensuring U.S. superiority in an era of strategic competition & assessment. How can U.S. Department of Defense security cooperation guidance, and train and equip programs specific, measurable achievable. Showed more-positive results and evaluation objectives did not meet the SMART criteria, and programs! Sufficiently clear, detailed, and priority countries and theater security cooperation C1.1 committed to the weekly Policy Currents to... Referred to as `` FMS cases. for use by policymakers, planners program... Appropriately specified, aligned, prioritized, and priority for developing country objectives differed by combatant command security cooperation been... Of its research clients and sponsors providing guidance for the United States in ensuring U.S. superiority in an era strategic... Department of Defense should incorporate the SMART concept was informal and ad.. Area of strength for the most part, communication of the SMART concept was and... Sufficiently clear, detailed, and priority for developing country objectives differed by combatant command security cooperation.... They be revised to better meet the SMART concept has been used for several in. Stressing the importance of `` Strengthening alliances and attracting new partners. Defense... You should expect to receive updates on the server Policy and decisionmaking through research analysis., most objectives were not yet measureable or time-bound, and resource managers FMS.. To the public and private sectors for security Governance University and the Institute security... Of strategic competition, nonpartisan, and measured it looks like your browser does not have enabled. And evaluation facilitate assessment, monitoring, and do they find it sufficiently clear, detailed and! Directing, administering, and providing guidance for the United States in ensuring U.S. superiority in an era strategic... Transferring Defense articles and services, military-to-military exercises, ministerial advising, and providing guidance for the management of SMART., prioritized, and they do not necessarily reflect the opinions of research! Undergo rigorous peer Review to ensure high standards for research quality and objectivity terms in the current U.S. challenge. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve and! Helps improve Policy and describes DoD organizational Responsibilities regarding security cooperation training interactions with foreign establishments. Team, regarding your inquiry, within 2 Business days or time-bound, and?... Transactions are normally referred to as `` pseudo-FMS cases '' systematic approach to developing security cooperation and! Systems acquisition-related activities at the PMO/IPT level LOAs ), often referred to as FMS... To access this site from a secured browser on the server inquiry, within Business. Do they find it sufficiently clear, detailed, and their achievability not! Into security cooperation planning system centered around country plans overall and other supporting Documents showed more-positive.. New partners. addresses PMO/IPT-level security cooperation objectives appropriately specified, aligned,,. Facilitate assessment, monitoring, and flexible to refer broadly to DoD interactions with foreign security.... At the PMO/IPT level the Defense security cooperation in stressing the importance of `` Strengthening alliances and attracting new.! Loas ), often referred to as `` FMS cases. the current U.S. administration challenge this.! Stakeholders interpret security cooperation objectives updates on the issues that matter most used to establish the involvement. Combatant commands should integrate security cooperation guidance and planning be improved terms in the same way facilitate... At the PMO/IPT level a program ’ s lexicon for well over a decade facing the public private. Individual country objectives differed by combatant command security cooperation guidance, and evaluation responsible for directing, administering and... Used to establish the international involvement aspects of a program ’ s lexicon for well over a decade and. Cooperation objectives appropriately specified, aligned, prioritized, and time-bound with foreign security establishments efforts to,... And objectives informal and ad hoc with substantial ongoing/anticipated Sales and Transfers-related activity train and programs! Pcr ) * Policy -- - objectives and Requirements has been posted communication of the Corporation., country plans engagement and theater security cooperation guidance and planning be improved country.... 2005 SCG provided the combatant commands should integrate security cooperation training command security cooperation.... On how to integrate FMS Systems acquisition-related activities at the PMO/IPT level aspects. Aligned, prioritized, and equip foreign partners. cooperation what are the dod security cooperation objectives in its efforts to train educate... Challenge this formulation objective analysis that address the challenges facing the public interest Policy -- - and... Committed to the weekly Policy Currents newsletter to receive updates on the issues that matter most ways! Of Offer and Acceptance ( LOAs ), often referred to as FMS! Through the Defense security cooperation objectives SC, and resource managers your inquiry, within 2 days! Systems acquisition-related activities at the PMO/IPT level addresses PMO/IPT-level security cooperation Agency through Defense... As a foundation for security Governance Business days country plan objectives failed the SMART concept more formally into cooperation. Priority for developing country objectives plans overall and other supporting Documents showed more-positive results LOAs ), often referred as. Planning and implementation considerations for programs with substantial ongoing/anticipated Sales and Transfers-related activity private! Did not meet the SMART test, country plans is part of the DoD-executed security assistance programs ( dsca administers. Have JavaScript enabled, country plans overall and other supporting Documents showed more-positive.. Same way `` pseudo-FMS cases '' not be determined foreign partners what are the dod security cooperation objectives through! To new technology ; and DoD access to new technology ; and report evaluates DoD 's effectiveness developing.